Anthony is a young, optimistic and overtly naïve musical theatre performer living in Big Timber, Montana with big Broadway dreams. Tony, on the other hand, is an extremely attractive and more than somewhat cocky stripper making big bucks in the Big Apple. Anthony dreams of his big break when he enters a contest to be in an Off-Broadway production in New York City. Tony sees dollar signs when he finds a competition called “America’s Strip Search!” Thanks to these contests being held by the same production company, and our leading men having the same name, an unexpected case of mistaken identity explodes. Horizons are broadened, lives are changed forever, and hilarity ensues.